top of page

Email Diplomacy: Macron's Response to the Left's Victory Under Fire

Democracy in Question: Macron's Letter to France’s, another manipulation technique?

The recent French legislative elections have resulted in a complex political landscape, challenging the traditional power dynamics in the Fifth Republic. President Emmanuel Macron's response to the results has raised questions about democratic norms and the future of governance in France.

On June 9th, Macron swiftly announced the dissolution of the National Assembly following the far-right's victory in the European Parliament elections. However, his reaction to the July 7th legislative elections, which saw significant gains for the organized left, has been markedly different. It took three days for the President to address the nation, and he did so through a letter rather than a more direct form of communication.

This delay and the chosen medium have been interpreted by some as a reluctance to fully acknowledge the electoral shift. Macron's letter, which suggested that "no political group had won," has been criticized as an attempt to downplay the left's gains and maintain his influence over potential coalition formations. The Prime Minister who presented his demission was rebutted and asked to continue to serve the country as the Olympics Games are fast approaching. Another slap in the face of the results that clearly had weakened the influence of Renaissance, the President’s political party.

The President's approach raises several concerns:

  1. Recognition of electoral outcomes: In a healthy democracy, it is crucial for leaders to promptly and clearly acknowledge election results, even when they are unfavorable to their position.

  2. Coalition-building process: Macron's suggestion that parties should propose coalitions that "suit him" could be seen as an overreach of presidential power in a parliamentary system.

  3. The role of the organized left: The left-wing alliance's strategic decisions during the campaign, including the withdrawal of candidates to prevent far-right victories, played a significant role in shaping the election outcome. Their contribution to preserving democratic norms deserves recognition.

  4. Government officials' statements: The Economy Minister's call for voters to avoid both left-wing and far-right parties has been criticized as potentially undermining democratic principles by equating diverse political ideologies.

Adding to the complexity of the situation are reports of dinners between government officials and far-right leaders, such as the meeting between the Minister of Defense and Marine Le Pen. These interactions are particularly concerning given Le Pen's past associations and the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. Moreover, the situation becomes even more alarming in light of reports that Russian President Vladimir Putin had called on French voters to support Le Pen's party. This foreign interference attempt underscores the delicate geopolitical implications of France's internal politics.

The revelation of Putin's attempt to influence French voters adds another layer of complexity to the political landscape. It raises questions about national sovereignty, the integrity of democratic processes, and the potential vulnerability of France's political system to external pressures. This development makes the reported meetings between government officials and far-right leaders even more troubling, as it could be perceived as inadvertently aligning with the interests of a foreign power that has actively sought to influence French politics.

As France navigates this new political reality, it is essential to maintain a commitment to democratic processes, transparent governance, and national security. The coming weeks will be crucial in determining how the various political forces can work together to address the nation's challenges while respecting the will of the electorate and safeguarding against foreign interference.

In conclusion, while it is important to recognize the complexity of forming a government in a fragmented political landscape, the principles of democratic representation, respect for electoral outcomes, and protection against foreign influence must remain paramount. The way forward for France will require dialogue, compromise, a renewed commitment to the foundational values of the Republic, and a vigilant stance against attempts to undermine its democratic institutions.


  1. Lettre du Président Emmanuel Macron aux Français. Publié le 10 juillet 2024 

  2. Législatives: Bruno Le Maire "ne met pas de signe égal entre le rn et LFI" mais "refuse de voter LFI » - BFM TV 

  3. La Russie de Poutine a apporté son soutien au Rassemblement national - LE MONDE 

  4. Révélations de «Libé» sur les dîners secrets avec le RN : Edouard Philippe assume, la macronie patauge, la gauche mitraille - LIBÉRATION 

  5. Chez Thierry Solère, les dîners secrets de la macronie et du RN - LIBÉRATION 


bottom of page